Debate Arena
Which side are you on? Take a moment and read through both sides. When you're ready cast your vote.
PFMEA Case Study #1: Differentiating Between Prevention (P) and Detection (D)
A Process Engineer develops a manufacturing plan for a new engine block. On similar existing manufacturing lines there were problems finding experienced machine operators. To avoid problems of the past, the engineer develops a training program for all new operators.
Is the training program a Process Control that can be ranked as Detection? The training will always provide experienced machine operators.
| Side A | Side B |
|---|---|
|
YES The training program IS a Process Control that can be ranked as Detection. |
NO The training program is NOT a Process Control that can be ranked as Detection. |
Current Debate Results
|
Your Opinion Counts! Take a moment to cast your vote - you don't even have to be a member. Choose a side from the argument above, and when you cast your vote the results are instantly updated! If you'd like to make a comment about this debate be sure to send us an email! We are very interested in everybody's feedback - regardless of which side you choose. Side A
Side B
|
Let us know what you think about the FMEA debate! Or, let us know if there is a topic you would like us to explore in the future. Contact PlanTech.